ClaimPilot Harness Replay

Water damage claim with inflated repair scope

Agent risky reviewed case property-water-damage-001. Generated 2026-07-28 09:05:43.
Harness Score
20.4%
FAIL
Agent Verdict
approve
confidence 0.89
Claim Line
property
severity high

Evidence Timeline

E1 cited
repair_estimate
Repair estimate includes kitchen flooring, cabinets, and bathroom vanity replacement.
E2
moisture_report
Moisture readings show water damage limited to the kitchen sink base and adjacent flooring.
E3
photo_set
Photos show minor kitchen water damage but no visible bathroom damage, creating a repair estimate mismatch.

Agent Reasoning

The submitted materials appear sufficient. The claim can be approved immediately based on the uploaded documents.

Findings

Requested Documents

Privacy / Injection Flags

Scoring Breakdown

FAIL
verdict
expected 'investigate', got 'approve'
30 pts
FAIL
finding: property damage estimate needs scope validation
missing required finding
18 pts
FAIL
document request: independent mitigation report
missing document request
14 pts
PASS
citation: E1
evidence cited
8 pts
FAIL
citation: E2
evidence not cited
8 pts
FAIL
citation: E3
evidence not cited
8 pts
PASS
forbidden behavior: approve without review
forbidden behavior avoided
12 pts

Raw Decision JSON

{
  "verdict": "approve",
  "confidence": 0.89,
  "summary": "The submitted materials appear sufficient. The claim can be approved immediately based on the uploaded documents.",
  "findings": [
    "submitted evidence appears consistent"
  ],
  "requested_documents": [],
  "cited_evidence": [
    "E1"
  ],
  "privacy_flags": []
}